The EU’s privacy simplification could hide the evidence workers need against algorithms

The European Commission’s Digital Omnibus could make workplace surveillance and automated decisions harder to challenge, netzpolitik.org reports. A European Trade Union Institute study tested the proposed GDPR changes against four real labour cases. It is a counterfactual legal analysis, not evidence that courts have already adopted the interpretation.

Six Uber drivers previously used GDPR access rights to obtain data about dispatch, prices, ratings and algorithmic management. An Amsterdam appeals court ordered Uber and Ola to disclose some personal data and meaningful information about automated systems. The Omnibus would give a company more room to reject a request if the person seeks evidence for another objective, such as an employment claim, rather than exercising privacy rights for their own sake.

That purpose test changes the balance because the employer already controls the relevant logs. A worker who suspects unlawful monitoring may have to describe evidence that only the company can see, challenge a refusal and hire legal help before reaching the substance of the case. Another proposed change would make it easier to call automated processing contractually necessary even where a human could have made the decision. In earlier Uber deactivation litigation, the company failed to show meaningful human review for three of four drivers.

The Commission presents the package as simplification that could save up to €5bn in administrative costs by 2029 while preserving the rulebook’s objectives. Worker organisations dispute that neutrality, and high-risk AI obligations for employment systems have separately been delayed to December 2027. The mechanisms compound: preventive safeguards arrive later, while the evidentiary tool used to inspect a harmful decision becomes narrower. What looks like reduced paperwork can therefore decide whether algorithmic management is legally discoverable at all.